Cases involving defendants with profound mental illness, intellectual disability, or cognitive impairment frequently require Fitness to Plead determinations under the Criminal Procedure (Insanity) Act 1964. In Crown Court billing, these proceedings involve complex two-stage trials that demand specialised billing treatment.
Practitioners must ensure both the preliminary fitness argument and any subsequent “trial of the facts” are accurately accounted for under LGFS and AGFS schemes.
1. The Two-Stage Remuneration Model
Where a defendant’s capacity is formally challenged, proceedings diverge into two distinct phases:
- Phase 1: Fitness Determination Hearing: A hearing before the judge (with or without a jury) to determine whether the accused is under a disability. This is remunerated under standard contested hearing or trial rates depending on duration.
- Phase 2: Trial of the Facts (Section 4A): If the defendant is found unfit, a jury is empanelled to determine whether the defendant did the act or made the omission charged. Under both LGFS and AGFS, this is remunerated as an effective jury trial.
2. Claiming Psychiatric and Medical Expert Disbursements
Fitness hearings require evidence from two or more registered medical practitioners, at least one of whom is Section 12 approved under the Mental Health Act 1983. Ensure prior authority was secured and that expert attendance fees are itemised with court arrival and departure times.
For more strategies on handling challenging case files, explore our guide on handling unusual work in complex Crown Court cases.