Receiving a reduced determination or disallowance notice from the Legal Aid Agency is a common challenge for criminal defence firms. However, a fee reduction is not the final word. The regulations provide a robust, multi-stage statutory appeal mechanism known as the Redetermination process.
Knowing how to navigate the 21-day deadline and draft persuasive grounds for redetermination is vital to protecting fee recovery in Crown Court billing.
1. The Statutory Framework: The 21-Day Redetermination Rule
Under Regulation 28 of the Criminal Legal Aid (Remuneration) Regulations 2013, a litigator or advocate dissatisfied with an assessment has the right to apply for a redetermination. Critical procedural requirements include:
- Strict 21-Day Deadline: The redetermination request must be submitted within 21 days of the initial notification date. Out-of-time requests require exceptional extension applications.
- CCCD Written Application: The request must be lodged directly through the CCCD portal, accompanied by written representations setting out the precise errors in the assessing officer’s decision.
- Targeted Evidence Submission: Only submit evidence directly addressing the specific ground of reduction (e.g., missed court logs, omitted NAE notices, or travel justification).
2. Escalating to a Costs Judge (Senior Courts Costs Office)
If the determining officer upholds the reduction upon redetermination, the practitioner can request written reasons. Within 21 days of receiving written reasons, the matter may be formally appealed to a Costs Judge of the Senior Courts Costs Office (SCCO):
| Appeal Level | Decision Maker | Remedy & Scope |
|---|---|---|
| Internal Redetermination | Senior LAA Determining Caseworker | Re-examination of calculations, missed hearings, and documentary evidence. |
| SCCO Costs Judge | Independent Judicial Costs Officer | Binding legal interpretation of remuneration regulations and fee caps. |
For an overview of how digital tools can help audit claims before submission to avoid disallowances entirely, see how digital Crown Court billing systems protect time and revenue.