While graduated fee schemes (LGFS and AGFS) cover the vast majority of standard Crown Court preparation, complex and voluminous criminal cases often demand additional remuneration. In these scenarios, defence solicitors and barristers rely on Special Preparation claims to recover costs for extraordinary preparation time.
Because Special Preparation claims are subject to intense individual assessment by Legal Aid Agency determining officers, submitting compliant evidence and contemporaneous time records is crucial.
1. Grounds for Claiming Special Preparation
Under the Criminal Legal Aid (Remuneration) Regulations 2013, Special Preparation is payable only where specific statutory criteria are satisfied:
- Excess PPE: Where served prosecution evidence exceeds the statutory graduated fee cap (normally 10,000 pages for litigators), additional reading is remunerated on an hourly rate basis.
- Extensive Digital Evidence: Where unserved or raw digital material (phone downloads, server logs, bank spreadsheets) must be examined, and the determining officer considers it reasonable to authorise extra hours.
- Novel or Complex Points of Law: Where novel legal arguments, extensive skeleton arguments, or complex abuse of process applications were required.
2. Documenting Special Preparation: The 4 Golden Rules
To clear LAA scrutiny without severe reductions, your submission must be supported by bulletproof documentation:
- Contemporaneous Time Logs: Every unit of time claimed must be recorded with date, start/end time, exact file reviewed, and purpose. Retrospective estimates are almost universally rejected.
- Reading Speed Feasibility: The LAA typically applies a guideline benchmark of 20 to 30 pages of complex technical text per hour. Claiming significantly higher reading speeds for simple logs or lower speeds without explanation invites drastic cuts.
- Detailed Justification Note: Provide a comprehensive case summary explaining why the material was pivotal to the defence theory and what issues arose during trial.
- DCS Corroboration: Ensure all documents referenced in your time sheets correspond directly to files accessible to the LAA assessor on the Crown Court Digital Case System.
Practitioners facing repeated assessment reductions should review our detailed guide on Crown Court billing mistakes to avoid to safeguard firm revenue.
One Response